Shingle vs. Tile: Which is Best For Your Replacement?

When it comes to replacing the roof on your home, one of the biggest decisions you’ll have to make is choosing shingles or tiles. Both have their unique set of pros and cons, so it can be difficult to decide which is best for your home. In this blog post, we’ll take a closer look at the differences between shingles and tiles and help you determine which option is the best for your replacement. We’ve got you covered whether you’re looking for durability, energy efficiency, or aesthetic appeal. So, read on to find out which roofing option will be the best for your home.

What is Tile Roofing?

Tile roofing is a popular option for replacement roofs because of its versatility and low cost. It’s made from durable materials, such as asphalt, clay, or concrete tiles, which are easy to install and maintain. There are a variety of tile types that can be used for roofing, including asphalt tiles, clay tiles, and concrete tiles. 

Tile roofing is weatherproof and durable, making it a popular choice for roofs in harsh climates. A tile roof provides extensive sky views and can last for many years. If you’re looking to make a significant investment in replacement roofing, tile roofing may be your best option. And with its advantages and favorable cost-benefit ratio, there’s no reason not to consider it when planning your roofing project.

What is Shingle Roofing?

Shingle roofs are a popular roofing option for homes of all sizes. They’re easy to install and economical, but they have some drawbacks that make tile roofing a better choice for many homeowners. Shingles offer durability and resistance to weathering, but they tend to be more costly to replace than tiles. They also need to be more durable in heavy snowfall or high winds. 

Shingles provide the same roofing benefits as shingles – durability, color options, and ventilation – but without the additional cost and hassle of installation. Regarding overall roofing durability, shingle roofs still lead the way. They’re highly durable and durable, providing years of protection against weather damage and decay. They’re easy to replace if damaged or worn out, making them a cost-effective option for homeowners who want an affordable roof that can stand up to the elements.

Tile Roofs vs. Shingle Roofs: The Difference

Tile roofs are made up of small, individual tiles that are bonded together. This roofing material is typically less expensive to install than a shingle roof, but it may require more maintenance over time. With a tile roof, the tiles can be decorated or colored to match the exterior of your home, and they are also less likely to develop cracks or break due to their durability. On the other hand, shingle roofs are made of large sheets of material, which are then attached to the roof with fasteners. These roofs require regular maintenance and should be cleaned and repaired as soon as they show signs of damage or wear. Since tile roofs last longer than shingle roofs if properly maintained, they’ve generally considered a more economical option overall.


Tile roofs are the most popular type of roof in the United States, accounting for around 50% of all residential roofing installations. They are made from a material called shingles, which are composed of small, overlapping tiles. Shingle roofs are made from large sheets of wood that are then covered in shingles. The shingles on tile roofs have a more traditional appearance and can be more expensive to install than shingle roofs, which have a more modern look and require smaller roof spaces. Shingle roofs are less durable than tile roofs and may require more maintenance than tile roofs. Overall, tile roofs are more aesthetically pleasing and versatile than shingle roofs. However, both types of roofing have their benefits and merits, and it depends on the homeowner’s specific needs and which one is best suited for their roofing needs.


Tile roofing is made of individual tiles installed on top of one another. On the other hand, shingle roofs are made of wood, plastic, or metal shingles installed over a prepared roof surface. The main advantage of tile roofing is its ease of installation and lower cost than shingle roofing. However, shingle roofs offer a more durable and aesthetically pleasing finished product. With tile roofs, you are more likely to need to replace them sooner than with a shingle roof, as they are more likely to require maintenance and damage. However, tile roofing and shingle roofing have advantages and can provide good value if they meet your needs and budget.


Tile roofs are more expensive than shingle roofs, but they last longer and require less maintenance. Shingle roofs are easy to install and require few repairs, but tile roofs may require more work. Shingle roofs are more insulated than tile roofs and may require additional insulation in colder climates. In addition, shingle roofs can be replaced with a simple repair kit; however, tile roofs cannot. With its greater durability, shingle roofing can be a more cost-effective option if your needs do not require the aesthetic appeal of tile roofing.


Shingle roofs are typically lighter than tile roofs, making them a better choice for high-rise buildings. However, tile roofs are more durable and longer-lasting than shingle roofs. They also have fewer roofing materials to worry about. Tile roofs are more expensive than shingle roofs, but they offer a wider range of aesthetic options. Shingle roofs require more maintenance than tile roofs, but they are easier to repair and maintain. Overall, it’s essential to consider the unique pros and cons of both types of roofing when deciding on the best roofing option for your project.


Tile roofs are a popular choice for homes in warm climates because they are well-suited to hot weather. On the other hand, shingle roofs are a good choice for homes in colder climates because they have greater durability and can be installed over existing roofing. Both tile and shingle roofs require periodic maintenance, but shingle roofs do not. Overall, it is essential to consider your climate when choosing the type of roofing that best suits your home. Whether your tile or shingle, look for quality materials and durability ratings when shopping for a new roof.


Tile roofs are durable and weather-resistant. They can withstand the elements, such as wind and rain, without leaking or deteriorating. On the other hand, shingle roofs may experience leaks or damage from weather conditions. However, due to their durability, tile roofs are less likely to experience leaks or damage than shingle roofs. Shingle roofs are more affordable than tile roofs but require occasional repairs, while tile roofs require a much smaller maintenance routine. Overall, both roof types have their advantages and disadvantages, depending on which one best suits your needs and preferences.


Tile roofs are more maintenance-intensive than shingle roofs. They require regular maintenance, such as cleaning and replacement of the roofing tiles, to stay in good condition. However, tile roofs provide longer lifespans and better weather protection than shingle roofs. On the other hand, shingle roofs require less maintenance than tile roofs and can be more expensive to replace if damaged or destroyed. If you live in a humid climate, there may be better options than a tile roof. A shingle roof is a good choice if you want an affordable replacement roof that requires minimal maintenance. These roofs cost less than tile roofs but offer superior weather protection and durability compared to other options.

Environmental Concerns

A shingle roof is a more environmentally-friendly option than a tile roof. A shingle roof uses less materials and does not require any sealants or adhesives, which reduces the impact of shingles on the environment. Shingle roofs also have a smaller carbon footprint than tile roofs because they are made with recycled materials. Overall, shingle vs. tile roofs is both good options for homeowners looking for durable and weather-resistant roofs that use sustainable materials. With proper maintenance, shingle vs. tile roofs can last many years without requiring replacement.

Resale Value

Tile roofs are often preferred for their looks and durability. They are less expensive to install and maintain than shingle roofs but may only last for a short time as a shingle roof. Shingle roofs typically have a longer lifespan due to their weather-resistant properties. They are typically more expensive regarding resale value, which is why tile roofs are sometimes chosen for projects with a high cost-to-reward ratio. However, there are many factors to consider before deciding the type of roofing material for your replacement project.


The roofing material you choose will depend on a few factors: the roofing type, your budget, and the roofing system you want. If you compare tile roofs and shingle roofs, they both offer durability, ease of maintenance, and low cost of installation and upkeep. They both have advantages and disadvantages, which help you make the right decision for your home. At AM Top Notch Roofing, we hope this comparison has helped you understand shingle roofing better and made your decision easier! To learn more, contact us today!

Posted in